Shopify Plus vs Open Source: The Total Cost of Ownership of Scaling in 2026

By EcommerceViews Editorial Team September 27, 2026 November 18, 2026 (updated) 18 min read
Beyond Shopify: The Total Cost of Ownership (TCO) of Scaling on Open-Source Architecture in 2026

Disclosure: the founder of EcommerceViews is Marketing Director at OpenCart, which appears in this comparison. He did not write or sign off this article. Read our conflict of interest note.

Most brands that pass £5 million a year on Shopify hit the same moment. The monthly bill is no longer a line item you ignore. There is the Plus fee, a stack of app subscriptions, and a 0.2% cut on every sale if you use your own payment processor. Someone on the team asks the obvious question: would it be cheaper to run our own store on WooCommerce or OpenCart?

If you haven’t settled on a setup yet, our guide to choosing an ecommerce architecture compares monolithic, headless and composable stores first.

The honest answer is that open-source ecommerce software is free, but running it is not. This Shopify Plus vs open source comparison breaks down the total cost of ownership: what a £5M store actually pays on Shopify Plus in 2026, then lists the costs that appear once you own the platform: hosting, security, developers and plug-ins. It ends with a three-year cost table and a plain view of which businesses gain from the move and which do not.

Shopify Plus vs open source: total cost of ownership in 2026

Shopify Plus vs open source at a glance

  • Shopify Plus pricing: from $2,300 a month on a three-year term (about £1,740), plus Shopify apps and a 0.2% fee on every sale if you use your own payment processor.
  • Open-source ecommerce: WooCommerce, OpenCart and Magento Open Source have no licence fee, but your business pays for managed hosting, security, PCI work and developers.
  • Three-year total cost at £5M a year: about £136,440 on Shopify Plus, £130,020 on WooCommerce and £133,080 on OpenCart in our model, before migration.
  • Migration: usually £40,000 to well over £110,000, which takes more than three years to pay back on fees alone.
  • Adobe Commerce: the licensed edition of Magento is priced on sales volume and is usually the most expensive route for a UK brand of this size.

What a £5M store pays on Shopify Plus

Shopify pricing on the Plus plan

Shopify Plus starts at $2,300 a month on a three-year term, or $2,500 a month on a one-year term. Shopify bills Plus in US dollars, so at September 2026 exchange rates that is about £1,740 to £1,890 a month, or £20,900 to £22,700 a year before you sell anything. Once monthly sales pass roughly $800,000 (about £600,000), Shopify moves many merchants to a variable fee instead. Shopify does not publish that rate, and industry reports put it between 0.25% and 0.40% of sales. A £5M store sells about £417,000 a month, so it usually stays on the flat fee for now.

Payment fees on Shopify

Payment fees come next. Shopify does not publish its Shopify Payments rates for Plus, and UK brands at this size negotiate them. For a reference point, Stripe’s standard rate for UK cards is 1.5% plus 20p. If you prefer your own processor, such as Adyen or a bank you already use, Shopify adds 0.2% per transaction. On £5 million in sales, that extra charge is £10,000 a year.

Shopify apps

Apps are where the bill grows quietly. Plus brands commonly spend about £750 to £3,800 a month on apps for subscriptions, bundles, search, loyalty and reviews. Some of those tools, like email marketing, you would pay for on any platform. Others exist only because Shopify does not do that job itself, and those are the ones an open-source store can replace.

Hosting and infrastructure

On Shopify, servers are someone else’s problem. On WooCommerce or OpenCart, they are yours. A £5M store with sale-day spikes needs more than a £25 shared plan.

Managed hosting costs

Managed WooCommerce hosts such as Pressable list premium single-site plans from $350 a month (about £265), and most stores at this size add a staging copy for testing updates. A cloud setup on AWS or a similar provider costs about the same once you include backups and database servers. Put a CDN and firewall in front of it, like Cloudflare Business at about £150 a month on annual billing, and a realistic budget is £550 to £750 a month. The larger cost is the planning. Someone has to check that the server can handle Black Friday before it arrives, not during it.

Security and PCI compliance

Who carries PCI scope

Shopify is a PCI DSS Level 1 service provider, so card security is mostly handled for you. When you self-host, the store and the server become part of your compliance scope. Most merchants keep that scope small by using hosted payment fields from Stripe, Braintree or Adyen, so card numbers never touch their server. You still have to patch WordPress, WooCommerce and every plug-in quickly, because attackers scan for known holes within days of a fix going public.

Security budget

Budget for malware scanning and off-site backups at around £75 a month. Add a yearly penetration test and quarterly vulnerability scans, which often run about £3,800 a year for a store this size. A single skimming incident on the checkout page costs far more than any of this, once you add refunds and card-scheme fines.

Developers and ongoing maintenance

WooCommerce maintenance

This is the line most founders underestimate. WooCommerce ships updates about once a month, and WordPress and PHP move on their own schedules. Each update needs testing on staging before it goes live, because one plug-in conflict can break checkout on a Saturday morning. Experienced WooCommerce developers charge about £75 to £150 an hour, and agencies offer maintenance retainers for large stores at £1,500 to £2,300 or more a month.

OpenCart and Shopify Plus developers

OpenCart has a smaller developer pool and fewer ready-made extensions, so more of the store ends up as custom code. That usually means paying a little more per month and depending on fewer people who know your setup. Shopify Plus stores still pay developers for theme and app work, but they do not pay anyone to keep the platform itself running.

Plug-in and Shopify app dependency costs

Leaving Shopify does not end plug-in spending. It changes its shape. WooCommerce extensions are sold as yearly licences, such as WooCommerce Subscriptions at about £210 a year or AutomateWoo at about £120 a year. A large store with ten to twenty paid plug-ins often spends £2,300 to £3,800 a year, which is much less than a Shopify app stack. The hidden cost is dependency. When a plug-in author stops updating their code, you either pay a developer to take it over or rebuild that feature. OpenCart extensions are usually one-time purchases, which looks cheaper, but many are sold by solo developers and are not always updated for new OpenCart versions. Before migrating, list every app you use today and check that each has a maintained open-source match.

Shopify API limits vs open-source control

Shopify’s GraphQL Admin API gives Plus stores 1,000 cost points per second, ten times the standard plan. That is enough for most order syncs and stock updates. It starts to pinch when an ERP pushes price changes across tens of thousands of variants, or when several apps compete for the same budget during a flash sale. Checkout changes are also limited to what Shopify’s Checkout Extensibility allows. WooCommerce and OpenCart have no platform-imposed rate limit. WooCommerce’s Store API rate limiting is off by default, so the real ceiling is your own server. You can also rewrite checkout and pricing logic yourself, down to the database. That freedom is the main reason large brands move, but every custom change is code your team has to keep working through future updates.

Where Magento Open Source and Adobe Commerce fit

When people compare Shopify Plus vs open source, Magento is often the third name on the list. It is worth understanding the two editions, because their costs are very different from WooCommerce and OpenCart.

Magento Open Source (formerly Community Edition)

Magento Open Source, previously called Magento Community Edition, is the free edition of the platform. Adobe bought Magento in 2018 and renamed the paid edition, then called Magento Commerce, to Adobe Commerce in 2021. The free edition kept the Magento name.

Like WooCommerce and OpenCart, Magento Open Source has no licence fee, but it is a heavier platform to run. A 2026 analysis by Ecommerce Partners puts hosting for mid-market Magento stores at roughly $5,000 to $15,000 a month, and says security patching alone can take 20 to 40 developer hours every quarter. Magento developers also cost more: the same analysis quotes $150 to $250 an hour, against $80 to $150 an hour for Shopify developers.

Adobe Commerce

Adobe does not publish a price list for Adobe Commerce. The licence is quoted individually and scales with your gross merchandise value (GMV), the total value of sales through the store. Partner estimates start at about $22,000 a year for the self-hosted version and about $40,000 a year on Adobe’s cloud for stores under $1 million in GMV, rising to $125,000 to $190,000 or more for large merchants.

A £5M store is roughly $6.6 million in GMV. Industry estimates for the $5 million to $10 million band are about $49,000 a year for the self-hosted licence and about $80,000 a year on cloud, before any development, hosting or apps. That licence alone is more than double the Shopify Plus platform fee in our model.

Magento and Adobe Commerce platform cost compared with Shopify Plus

The table below shows typical annual platform cost ranges for mid-market brands, as estimated by Ecommerce Partners in US dollars. They are wider than our UK model because they cover a broader range of store sizes.

Annual cost (US mid-market) Shopify Plus Magento Open Source Adobe Commerce
Platform licence $2,300/month on a 3-year term $0 About $40,000+ a year, based on GMV
Hosting and infrastructure Included $24,000 to $180,000 Included on cloud
Security and PCI compliance Included $5,000 to $25,000 Partly included
Agency or developer retainer $10,000 to $30,000 $15,000 to $60,000 $20,000 to $80,000
Total annual platform cost $41,000 to $120,000 $59,000 to $330,000 $75,000 to $325,000

For most UK merchants at £5 million, Magento only makes sense when the business has needs that WooCommerce cannot meet, such as complex B2B accounts, very large catalogues or several stores run from one back office. Otherwise, WooCommerce is the cheaper open-source option, and staying on Shopify Plus is often cheaper still.

Three-year Shopify Plus vs open source cost comparison at £5M a year

The table below models a UK store with £5 million in yearly sales and about 50,000 orders a year. It leaves out costs that are the same on every platform, such as card processing on Shopify Payments or Stripe and your email marketing tool. Figures are estimates in pounds, excluding VAT, based on published 2026 pricing and typical agency rates. Shopify, Cloudflare and most plug-in sellers bill in US dollars, so those lines are converted at about $1.32 to the pound (September 2026) and will move with the exchange rate.

Cost over 3 years Shopify Plus WooCommerce OpenCart
Platform licence £62,640 (about £1,740/month, 3-year term) £0 £0
Hosting, CDN and firewall Included £25,920 £19,080
Security and PCI work Included (Level 1 provider) £14,100 £14,100
Maintenance overhead (developers) £41,400 (themes and apps only) £81,000 (£2,250/month retainer) £95,400 (£2,650/month retainer)
Plug-in or app dependency £32,400 (Shopify-only apps at £900/month) £9,000 (yearly licences) £4,500 (one-time buys plus upgrades)
API limits 1,000 points/second on GraphQL; checkout via extensions only No platform limit; set by your server No platform limit; set by your server
Migration (one-time) £0 £57,000 £68,000
3-year total £136,440 £187,020 £201,080
3-year total without migration £136,440 £130,020 £133,080

Two things change these numbers. If you use your own payment processor on Shopify, add £30,000 for the 0.2% fee, which puts Plus at £166,440. And on an open-source store you can negotiate processing rates freely. Saving 0.3 percentage points on £5 million is £15,000 a year, or £45,000 over three years.

Three-year cost of Shopify Plus vs open source (WooCommerce and OpenCart) for a £5M UK store

Three-year cost of Shopify Plus vs open source for a £5M UK store, with and without migration

Migration costs and who should move

The move itself is the biggest single bill. Agencies commonly quote from about £40,000 for a simple catalogue to well over £110,000 when ERP links and custom checkout rules are involved. Plan for URL redirects and a few weeks of lower search traffic while Google re-indexes the new store. On the table above, WooCommerce only pulls ahead of Shopify Plus in running costs, and the migration takes more than three years to pay back on fees alone. The math improves if you already pay the 0.2% gateway fee or your app bill is well above £900 a month. The case gets stronger still when Shopify’s limits block something you need, like complex B2B pricing or a heavily custom checkout. It also helps to have a developer or agency you trust before you start. A brand that sells a simple catalogue and has no in-house tech lead will usually spend less, and sleep better, staying on Plus.

How to work out your own ecommerce TCO

Our model is a starting point, not your answer. Your own ecommerce TCO (total cost of ownership) depends on your apps, payment rates and team. To compare Shopify Plus vs open source for your store:

  1. List every Shopify app you pay for and mark which ones you would still need on any platform, such as email marketing, and which exist only because of Shopify.
  2. Check your payment fees. Note whether you pay the 0.2% charge for using your own processor, and what rate you could negotiate elsewhere.
  3. Price managed hosting for your peak traffic, not your average day, including a staging copy, CDN and firewall.
  4. Get two or three maintenance quotes from WooCommerce, OpenCart or Magento agencies, based on your real catalogue and integrations.
  5. Add security and PCI work: malware scanning, backups, vulnerability scans and a yearly penetration test.
  6. Get a migration quote that includes data import, redirects and testing, and spread it over three to five years.

Compare the totals over the same period. If the open-source total is not clearly lower after migration, the platform change is about control, not cost.

Shopify Plus or open source: which suits your business?

Stay on Shopify Plus if

  • you sell a fairly simple catalogue and Shopify’s checkout does what you need
  • you have no in-house tech lead or trusted agency
  • you use Shopify Payments and your app bill is under about £900 a month
  • you would rather pay a predictable monthly fee than manage servers and updates

Move to open-source ecommerce if

  • Shopify’s limits block something you need, like complex B2B pricing or a custom checkout
  • you already pay the 0.2% gateway fee or your app bill is well above £900 a month
  • you have a developer or agency you trust to run the store long term
  • owning your code and data matters more to the business than convenience

Conclusion

At £5 million a year, open source is not the easy cost cut it looks like from the Shopify invoice. The licence fee disappears, but hosting and a monthly developer retainer take its place, and the migration bill can wipe out three years of savings. WooCommerce is the safer open-source choice because of its larger developer pool and regular updates. OpenCart can cost less to host but asks more of your developers. Move when you need control Shopify will not give you, or when your fees and apps are well above the numbers in this table. Before deciding, price your own app list and payment rates line by line, since those figures decide the outcome more than the platform name does.

Frequently asked questions

Is open source cheaper than Shopify Plus?

Not always. In our model for a £5M UK store, WooCommerce and OpenCart cost slightly less to run than Shopify Plus over three years, but the one-off migration makes them more expensive overall. Open source pulls ahead when you pay Shopify’s 0.2% gateway fee or a large app bill.

How much does Shopify Plus cost per month?

Shopify Plus starts at $2,300 a month on a three-year term or $2,500 a month on a one-year term. Larger merchants can be moved to a variable fee based on sales. Apps, themes and payment fees are extra.

What is the difference between Magento Open Source and Adobe Commerce?

Magento Open Source, formerly Community Edition, is free to use, and you host and maintain it yourself. Adobe Commerce is the licensed edition, previously Magento Commerce, with extra features, Adobe support and an optional cloud version. Its licence fee depends on your sales volume.

Is WooCommerce enough for a £5M store?

Yes, with the right setup. A store this size needs managed hosting built for traffic peaks, a CDN and firewall, and a maintenance retainer so that updates are tested before they go live.

What does ecommerce TCO include?

Total cost of ownership covers everything you pay to run the store over several years: platform licence, hosting, security and PCI work, developers, apps or plug-ins, payment fees and any migration.

Does moving off Shopify Plus hurt SEO?

It can for a while. Plan URL redirects for every product, category and content page, and expect a few weeks of lower search traffic while Google re-indexes the new store.

Sources

E

Written by

EcommerceViews Editorial Team

The EcommerceViews editorial team writes and signs off our platform reviews and rankings, including all our coverage of OpenCart. Every review follows our published review process, and no platform pays to be included or sees a review before it goes live.